. Acts 9:7 states that when Jesus called Paul to preach the gospel, the men who were with Paul heard a voice but saw no man: "And the men which journeyed with him stood speechless, hearing a voice, but seeing no man.". In this episode of The Tent Making Christianity QCQ Podcast, the team discusses whether there is a contradiction in Paul's conversion story. This is an important point based on the fact that Luke, the author of the book of Acts, traveled with the Apostle Paul. . The Conversion of Paul In the three versions of Paul's conversion (Acts 9:1-9, 22:6-11, 26:9-20), there are repeated elements which appear to be central to his mission and commissioning. He tells us that fourteen years after that, he went with Barnabas and Titus. The Apostle Paul is a Christian icon. Paul's purpose in the cited passage in Galatians is not to provide a thorough travel log since his conversion (he skips huge blocks of time), but to present his apostolic credentials (see Gal. Thus in Acts 9:7, "hearing the voice," the noun "voice" is in the partitive genitive case [i.e., hearing (something) of], whereas in 22:9, "they heard not the voice," the construction is with the accusative. New episodes are released every Thursday. He did a complete 180 and started preaching the faith he was once determined to destroy. by Richard Carrier on June 6, 2015 104 Comments. A problem for interpretation and for harmonization involves the superficial contradiction between Acts 9 in which Paul moves about freely in Jerusalem, staying with the Apostles, speaking boldly in the name of the Lord, talking and debating with the Hellenistic, or Grecian Jews. Paul's vision of Jesus reflects Jesus' own vision of the descending Spirit (Luke 3:22). The company's principal address is 915 N 150 E Apt 307, Provo, UT 84604. I will assume here Paul's conversion in AD 35 (others would go +/- a couple years): Acts 22:9 reads, "And they that were with me [Paul] saw indeed the light, and were afraid; but they heard not the voice of . Either Paul was 1.) Paul's traveling companions served as authenticators that what happened to Paul was an objective . 3. The transformation of persecuting Saul of Tarsus into the apostle Paul is a typical example of the work of grace in the heart. This also has use as some scholars ignorantly claim that any standard that would deny the historicity of Jesus would . Daniel Marguerat's work has long served as a model of historically informed, literarily sensitive, theologically attuned exegesis. Sort of. All four Gospels confirm it as do various epistles. 2. It is a phenomenal transformation of consciousness, which is why he becomes such a courageous teacher of what he is convinced is the . The Registered Agent on file for this company is Paul D Quakenbush and is located at 915 N 150 E apt 307, Provo, UT 84604. While on his way to Damascus, Paul saw what he believed to be the risen Jesus. "When Paul says that after he converted on the way to Damascus he did not go to Jerusalem to see those who were apostles before him (Gal. As Jesus receives the Spirit at his baptism, so does Paul at the hands of Ananias (Acts 9:17). The supposed contradictions that the web site you link to gives are strained, at best. They are found in chapters 9 and 22. For this comparison, we are only using the first two. #51 Twilight Hue, Jun 28, 2019. He poses a quadrilemma. Acts 22:9 And they that were with me saw indeed the light, and were . "Saul's Conversion (Acts 9, 22, 26) and the Multiplication of . SAB Contradictions 469. . However, the revelations concerning Paul did not stop there. Paul's Conversion ExperienceTuesday, March 31, 2015. critical classification of the narratives of Paul's conversion/call. During the Shabir Ally / Thomas Ross debate, "The New Testament Picture of Jesus: Is It Accurate?" Dr. Shabir Ally claimed that the Bible contained a number . In Acts 26,Paul says that Yeshua told him of his plans for him at the time of the vision on the road to Damascus: "It was on the road at midday, Your Majesty, that I saw a In Acts 9:7 we are told that his . (Read the entire passage starting from Acts 9:17.) Resolving the contradiction involves translating and in Acts 9:7 as "hear" and "sound" respectively, but translating the same words in Acts 22:9 as "understand" and "voice". 4 For a good summary of the debate over apparent contradictions in the descriptions of Paul's travel companions, see C. K. Barrett, . 1:11-12; 2:6-9). In fact claiming "Arabia" contradicts the events in Acts requires one to ignore what the verse plainly states. The writer of Acts gives no time limitations here. St. Paul's biographer, intimate friend and most dear physician (Gal. Compare them closely to one another, and you find very odd contradictionsIn chapter 9 Paul's companions hear the voice of Jesus talking to Paul, but they don't see anyone; in chapter 22 they see light but don't hear anything. A Man of Contradictions Monday, March 30, 2015. Paul's conversion experience is discussed in both the Pauline epistles and in the Acts of the Apostles. There is no Bible contradiction between Acts 9 and 22 in the descriptions of Paul's conversion on the road to Damascus. Let's take a look at both verses before we continue and see what they do and do not say. A Man of Contradictions. Walter J. Cummins graduated from the Power for Abundant Class in 1962. My book on the "Triumph of Christianity" will deal with how and why people converted to the Christian faith. Paul's pre-encounter persecutions of the early church, the heavenly light, . Where as in Galatians 1 he writes, "I was personally unknown . This new book brings together English translations of many of Marguerat's more recent essays, along with a couple of new pieces, into a single collection broadly unified by the overarching theme suggested by the title, Paul in Acts and Paul in His Letters. Investigating Paul's story is what turned a formerly self-proclaimed infidel into a believer and Christian apologist. It is true that Saul/Paul did not claim to have known or seen Jesus of Nazareth prior to His crucifixion. In the book of Acts we have not one, not two, but three accounts of Saul's conversion. Learning From The Accounts Of Paul's Conversion The events which occurred when Paul met the Lord on his way to Damascus are described three times in the book of Acts. The second is found in Acts chapter 22. The difficulty that needs to be solved concerns what the men with Paul saw and heard. Which is it?" Here are the verses: 2.) To begin, it is important to understand that the belief that the book of Acts has a contradiction is not related to the Apostle Paul's personal conversion story. You can read a discussion of their differences in Paul: the Stranger, my book that exposes Paul as a liar and . We will have no other preface, but proceed at once to two or three considerations. Spartan Well-Known Member. Here's a sample from the major focus points: Acts 9:7 And the men which journeyed with him stood speechless, hearing a voice, but seeing no man. When we come to Galatians 1:11-12, Paul defends his ministry by discussing the manner of how he received the Gospel. Jesus' gospel and the gospel of the Twelve was Jesus was the promised Messiah. Witherington comments: "without question, the story of Saul's 'conversion' is one of the most important events, if not the most important event, that Luke records in Acts."2 Perhaps this lends a clue as to why Luke includes Paul's conversion account no less than three times in Acts 9, 22, 26, with Paul adding two ad- ditional . But I think that we sometimes fail to appreciate the evidential power of Paul's conversion. 2. There are two accounts of Saul's (Paul's) conversion in the book of Acts that have come under attack. The columns on the far right and left sides of chart 15-17 show the verses of these six accounts in which each . Lumify Led Conversion is an Utah Dba filed On March 3, 2017. a liar. This is a big deal because Jesus' followers were preaching bodily resurrection from day one. Finally, Paul's encounter outside Damascus was not his "conversion": No one today preaches one is saved by believing Jesus was the promised Messiah. Even though it is clear that there is an early record about the creed of 1 Corinthians 15:3-8, we now must ask if this implies a contradiction with Galatians 1: 11-12. Acts 9:7 states, "And the men which journeyed with him [Paul] stood speechless, hearing a voice, but seeing no man.". "Mystery" solved! Paul's traveling companions served as authenticators that what happened to Paul was an objective . Monday, March 30, 2015. We assume that Acts is written by Luke about twenty years after Paul wrote most of his . Not fearing any contradiction, Luke used the same words, knowing that the reader would realize what sense the author meant by the words in each context by comparing the accounts. Paul's Conversion Experience Did God audibly speak or not? God has a purpose in electing Israel. Although Acts chapters 9,22, and 26 all indicate that Paul went from Damascus to Jerusalem after he became a Christian, one must realize that none of these passages specifically says that Paul went straight from Damascus to Jerusalem. Agnostic New Testament scholar Bart Ehrman says, "the book of Acts in the New Testament contains historically unreliable information about the life and teachings of Paul." In his book, Jesus, Interrupted Dr. Ehrman provides five examples of contradictions that exist between Paul's letters and Acts.
"The life and words of Saint Paul are filled with irony and contradiction. The alleged contradiction is easily resolved. This was the beginning of Saul's ministry for Jesus, who became Paul. Again we don't even have to go this far all we have to demonstrate that Ephesians 5 and Romans 6, are logical contradictions to the interpretations that Paul was implying that he was still a chief sinner after his conversion in 1 Tim 1:15. There are three passages that relay the events of Paul's conversion. It is a phenomenal transformation of consciousness, which is why he becomes such a courageous teacher of . Three years later he went to Jerusalem, where he met with the apostles. 153. Yet the powers that were are blamed for condemning Christ. According to both sources, . 26, the author (Luke) indicates that he is actually quotingPaul rather than merely describing the conversion as he did in Acts 9. A Possible Contradiction in Paul's Conversion? To date, the nature of Paul's conversion experience remains indeterminate for those who refuse to believe the simple, straight forward account given in the Bible.
If there is an example of irresistible grace, the story of Paul's conversion certainly represents it, but let's unpack it and see if it teaches what Calvinism suggests: 1. One historian has expressed the matter in the following way. He suffered dramatically for his faith, was challenged regularly by those in authority and even stood up to the Apostle Peter when it was needed. The conversion of Saul/Paul is so important to the author of the Book of Acts that he presents the story three times (Acts 9, 22, 26). The first is found in Acts chapter 9 . I am often enough asked what evidence there is for the historical existence of Paul that a summary write up would be handy to refer people to. Joined: Apr 15, 2019 Messages: 2,553 Ratings: +289 Religion: Christian. Likes Received: 1. Paul Tobin, in an article titled "Internal Contradictions in the Bible," summed up the skeptic's argument by stating that 1 Samuel 16 "clearly shows that Davidwas known to Saul. . Are these texts actually contradictory? . Yet a little later, after David's fight with Goliath, Saul is made to inquire from his chief captain as to the identity of the giant slayer (I Samuel 17:56). But the more he immersed himself in Scripture the more he found to support the Catholic faith, and in 1992 he entered the Catholic Church. Apart from all this, however, a woman could still receive the gift of prophecy from God without any conflict arising with St. Paul's legislation forbidding women to teach or usurp authority. Introducing St. Paul. 2 Cor.11:8. Alma's conversion is given in Mosiah 27, Alma 36, and 38. Planning on becoming a Protestant seminary professor, he started an intensive study of the Bible. Preston A. Vickrey (humbly) ( talk) 21:12, 17 April 2010 (UTC) [ reply] I assume these comments relate to material which no longer exists. There's no contradictions in the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Over the last seven years I have come to believe that either directly or indirectly the teachings . The Significance of Paul's Conversion The conversion of Saul, that rabid persecutor of the early church, is one of the most significant events in the history of the first-century church. According to Acts 22:9, however, the men saw a light but didn't hear . Refutation of 194 Biblical "Contradictions" (#151-175) [4-11-22] 176) Paul teaches not to steal. The argument goes that Saul had some kind of conversion from radical Pharisaic Judaism to belief in Christ, but that Saul/Paul had zero interaction with the dead Rabbi Jesus. Acts 9:26 does not say how long after Paul's conversion he went to Jerusalem, it merely says that he eventually went to Jerusalem.
Acts 9:7-8 (NKJV) In Galatians Paul says that he was converted by direct revelation of Christ, that he did not go to Jerusalem at that time, but went instead to "Arabia." After that, he returned to Damascus. 1:16-17), whereas the book of Acts says that that was the first thing he did after leaving Damascus (Acts 9:26 . critical classification of the narratives of Paul's conversion/call. Acts 9, Shabir Ally argued, claimed that the companions of Saul of Tarsus did not hear the voice of the risen Christ, while Acts 22, Dr. deceived by others 4.) Skeptics have claimed that there is a contradiction in these two accounts regarding the witnesses of Saul's experience. It only says, "And when Saul had come to Jerusalem.". The transformation of persecuting Saul of Tarsus into the apostle Paul is a typical example of the work of grace in the heart. There are conflicting accounts of Paul's conversion. First, it marked his conversion to Christianity; second, it constituted his call to be a prophet; and third, it served as his commission to be an apostle. Ehrman writes, "These are just a few of the discrepancies that one can . In chapter 9, the witnesses, "heard the voice, but saw no one.". As early as 1932, Hans Windisch and others had noted the similarity in structure between Paul's conversion in Acts and the Heliodorus legend in 2 Maccabees 3 and other Hellenistic parallels.9 Recently Gerhard Lohfink has analyzed the Christophany in Acts 9:4-6, 22:7-10, (Paul Carlson: New Testament Contradictions) "Some translations of the Bible (the New International Version and the New . The first says that they didn't see anyone and the second says that they did see light. All conversions are in a high degree similar to this pattern conversion. He received his Bachelor of Science degree in Education from Ohio State University in 1968 and his Master of Education degree in Secondary School Administration in 1978 from Wright State University. At first reading the conversion accounts seem to present a contradiction. No two of these accounts are exactly the same. 2. 5. Ally claimed, affirmed that Paul's companions did har the voice of the Lord Jesus. . No, Paul did no go straight to Jerusalem after his conversion. Watch the video below to find out.
Acts 22:9 reads, "And they that were with me [Paul] saw indeed the light, and were afraid; but they heard not the voice of . He essentially wrote half of the New Testament as he carried the gospel far and wide. Paul's Conversion. Paul's conversion: Contradictory accounts? Paul considered himself to be charged directly by Jesus to preach the same message. A List of Contradictory and Incompatible Statements. This removes the idea of any contradiction. Luke and Paul probably discussed the conversion story in depth. As early as 1932, Hans Windisch and others had noted the similarity in structure between Paul's conversion in Acts and the Heliodorus legend in 2 Maccabees 3 and other Hellenistic parallels.9 Recently Gerhard Lohfink has analyzed the Christophany in Acts 9:4-6, 22:7-10, But supplementation is not the same as contradiction. Acts 9:7 states, "And the men which journeyed with him [Paul] stood speechless, hearing a voice, but seeing no man.". Paul's gospel is a grace gospel, not a kingdom gospel. Answer (1 of 22): Because Paul doesn't contradict Jesus's teachings. Listen to our Weekly Quick Challenge Question Podcast on iTunes, Google Play Music or Stitcher. There is no contradiction with Paul's encounter in Acts 9 or his testimony in Acts 22 or Acts 26 with this letter. This lack of harmony concerning Paul's conversion in Acts not only betrays a lack of personal knowledge of Paul, but that its author or authors were using more than one source to recount the tale of Paul's conversion. Paul's life is a reflection of Jesus life , it's the reason Paul seems exalted to Gentiles they hadn't known the scriptures but Paul was a Pharisee and knew them well he was able to take the message in the prophets and speak it to Gentiles intelligibly to explain the revelation of Christ they hold without the hearer having to know scripture. Messages: 9,638. The former indicates a hearing of the sound, the latter indicates the meaning or . After all, it was the "Apostle" Paul. The biggest contradiction is Pauline Christianity dealing with Paul's conversion. THE CONVERSION OF SAINT PAUL THE VALIDITY OF HIS TESTIMONY TO THE RESURRECTION OF JESUS CHRIST Rev. And Ananias even administers a baptismal rite aimed at washing away sins (Acts 22:16), just as John does (Luke 3:3). 4:14), Luke, describes Saul on a journey to Damascus. another new testament illustration of this literary phenomenon is the record of paul's conversion, as set forth three times in the book of acts (chapters 9, 22, and 26).this repetition has puzzled some sincere bible students.others, searching for flaws in the sacred scriptures, contend that the repetition is superfluous and contradictory, and Each version is different, and this fact has led some critics to say that the accounts are contradictory.
Please explain the apparent contradiction between Acts 9:7 and 22:9, concerning Paul's conversion. crazy 3.) The Contradictions of Paul - Part 1 For a number of years I've raised an occasional eyebrow to some of Paul's teachings; but I never took the time to dig very deep. St. Paul says that the powers that be are ordained of God, and that we must not resist them. In this episode of The Tent Making Christianity QCQ Podcast, the team discusses whether there is a contradiction in Paul's conversion story. The stories differ slightly. Please explain the apparent contradiction between Acts 9:7 and 22:9, concerning Paul's conversion. Thus, regardless of how one works through the accounts of Paul's conversion, an appeal to different cases probably ought not form any part of the solution [Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics, 133-134]. 01 - Paul's Conversion -The Itineraries Of Paul. There is no contradiction because one can easily see light without seeing a person. A fter Paul's long exhortation to live without sin in our lives as Christians Romans 7:14 completely . (As I think I've said, unlike some scholars I have no problem calling the earliest followers of Jesus who came to believe in his resurrection "Christian.") The best known and most important conversion was Paul. . Paul's conversion experience on the Damascus Road, which we'll explore in more depth tomorrow, is the source of his immense inner authority and most of his themes. June 16, 2016. Paul's gospel of salvation is Christ died for our sins and rose again (1 Corinthians 15.1-4). HUMANIST QUESTION: As a final example of a New Testament contradiction, the conflicting accounts of Paul's conversion can be cited.Acts 9:7 states that when Jesus called Paul to preach the gospel, the men who were with Paul heard a voice but saw no man. By Erik Manning. In his October 1, 2000 Angelus address in St. Peter's Square, Pope John Paul II said, "The document [Dominus Iesus] thus expresses once again the same ecumenical passion that is the basis of my encyclical Ut Unum Sint.I hope this declaration, which is close to my heart, can, after so many erroneous interpretations, finally fulfill its function both of clarification and openness" (Zenit . No Contradiction . Good question. Paul admits to stealing. As you continue to read in acts and his letters to the saints, you will see his faithfulness to Jesus, who he once persecuted. January 31, . The company's filing status is listed as Active and its File Number is 10284758-0151. To bring the Messiah and his message of redemption to the world. In Acts there are three testimonies of Paul's conversion on his way to Damascus.
As we will see over the next three weeks, all of Paul's major themes are contained in seed form in his conversion experience, of which there are three descriptions in Acts (chapters 9, 22, and 26). The criticism is that there are contradictions in them. We will have no other preface, but proceed at once to two or three considerations. I've copied a footnote from my lesson on the text in Galatians 1 which addresses your question: 35 Paul's account of his first visit to Jerusalem does not conflict with that of Luke in Acts 9:26-30. When was Paul's first visit to Jerusalem after his conversion? The conversion of Saul/Paul is so important to the author of the Book of Acts that he presents the story three times (Acts 9, 22, 26). The first is not difficult, for the two passages don't contain any apparent discrepancy. Jimmy was born in Texas, grew up nominally Protestant, but at age 20 experienced a profound conversion to Christ. As stated in part 1 of the Contradictions of Paul; in 2010 my eyes were opened regarding Paul, the supposed "apostle to the Gentiles." At that time, I began to see how Paul's words did not lineup with the teachings of Jesus Christ. According to both sources, . Book Of Mormon Contradiction: Alma 18:24-29 June 28, 2022; Today's Prayer (06/27/2022) June 27, 2022; Eph.4:28. Don't see your podcast listening platform? There is no contradiction because one can easily see light without seeing a person. Resolving the contradiction involves translating and in Acts 9:7 as "hear" and "sound" respectively, but translating the same words in Acts 22:9 as "understand" and "voice". All conversions are in a high degree similar to this pattern conversion. Apr 22, 2021. The story of Paul's conversion from a devout Jew, violently persecuting believers in Jesus, to a devout Christian, fearlessly spreading the Gospel against all opposition, is found three times in Acts. He was a devout Jew who believed strongly in his faith and consequently persecuted the early Christians, participating even in the stoning of Stephen (Acts 7:58 says that the men stoning Stephen laid their coats at his feet). In Acts 9 it seems that the bystanders also heard the voice that was speaking to Paul, but in Acts 22 it seems that they didn't hear that voice. Luke tells us that Paul fled to Jerusalem from Damascus, attempted to associate with the "disciples" there (Acts 9:26), and was shunned until Barnabas took him to the . I won't go through every one point by point, but just for example: #2: Paul said "For I did not receive it [his doctrines] from man, now wa. The I tackle and refute all 51 supposed Bible "contradictions" suggested by anti-theist atheist Paul Carlson in his pathetic hit-piece, "New Testament Contradictions" (The Secular Web, 1995). . The following statements from Paul's letters are symptomatic of deep differences between the doctrines of Paul and Jesus -- much as a fever is symptomatic of an infection in the body. Paul's conversion experience is discussed in both the Pauline epistles and in the Acts of the Apostles. Joseph L. Lilly, C.M., S.T.D., S.S.L. The first account, in Acts 9, narrated Paul's conversion when it actually happened. The man quoted more often than Jesus, from the gospel accounts. Paul's conversion experience on the Damascus Road, which we'll explore in more depth tomorrow, is the source of his immense inner authority and most of his themes. The Historicity of Paul the Apostle. First there was the brief historical sketch by Luke in Acts 9. . 3. The man noted for writing the lion's share of the New Testament. Interestingly, in each case we have three accounts of their conversions: Paul's conversion is reported in Acts 9, 22, and 26. The intensity of St. Paul's feelings, smarting . Each version is different, and this fact has led some critics to say that the accounts are contradictory. Armed with pontifical letters of authorization to the synagogues His name is George Lyttleton.
"The life and words of Saint Paul are filled with irony and contradiction. The alleged contradiction is easily resolved. This was the beginning of Saul's ministry for Jesus, who became Paul. Again we don't even have to go this far all we have to demonstrate that Ephesians 5 and Romans 6, are logical contradictions to the interpretations that Paul was implying that he was still a chief sinner after his conversion in 1 Tim 1:15. There are three passages that relay the events of Paul's conversion. It is a phenomenal transformation of consciousness, which is why he becomes such a courageous teacher of . Three years later he went to Jerusalem, where he met with the apostles. 153. Yet the powers that were are blamed for condemning Christ. According to both sources, . 26, the author (Luke) indicates that he is actually quotingPaul rather than merely describing the conversion as he did in Acts 9. A Possible Contradiction in Paul's Conversion? To date, the nature of Paul's conversion experience remains indeterminate for those who refuse to believe the simple, straight forward account given in the Bible.
If there is an example of irresistible grace, the story of Paul's conversion certainly represents it, but let's unpack it and see if it teaches what Calvinism suggests: 1. One historian has expressed the matter in the following way. He suffered dramatically for his faith, was challenged regularly by those in authority and even stood up to the Apostle Peter when it was needed. The conversion of Saul/Paul is so important to the author of the Book of Acts that he presents the story three times (Acts 9, 22, 26). The first is found in Acts chapter 9 . I am often enough asked what evidence there is for the historical existence of Paul that a summary write up would be handy to refer people to. Joined: Apr 15, 2019 Messages: 2,553 Ratings: +289 Religion: Christian. Likes Received: 1. Paul Tobin, in an article titled "Internal Contradictions in the Bible," summed up the skeptic's argument by stating that 1 Samuel 16 "clearly shows that Davidwas known to Saul. . Are these texts actually contradictory? . Yet a little later, after David's fight with Goliath, Saul is made to inquire from his chief captain as to the identity of the giant slayer (I Samuel 17:56). But the more he immersed himself in Scripture the more he found to support the Catholic faith, and in 1992 he entered the Catholic Church. Apart from all this, however, a woman could still receive the gift of prophecy from God without any conflict arising with St. Paul's legislation forbidding women to teach or usurp authority. Introducing St. Paul. 2 Cor.11:8. Alma's conversion is given in Mosiah 27, Alma 36, and 38. Planning on becoming a Protestant seminary professor, he started an intensive study of the Bible. Preston A. Vickrey (humbly) ( talk) 21:12, 17 April 2010 (UTC) [ reply] I assume these comments relate to material which no longer exists. There's no contradictions in the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Over the last seven years I have come to believe that either directly or indirectly the teachings . The Significance of Paul's Conversion The conversion of Saul, that rabid persecutor of the early church, is one of the most significant events in the history of the first-century church. According to Acts 22:9, however, the men saw a light but didn't hear . Refutation of 194 Biblical "Contradictions" (#151-175) [4-11-22] 176) Paul teaches not to steal. The argument goes that Saul had some kind of conversion from radical Pharisaic Judaism to belief in Christ, but that Saul/Paul had zero interaction with the dead Rabbi Jesus. Acts 9:26 does not say how long after Paul's conversion he went to Jerusalem, it merely says that he eventually went to Jerusalem.
Acts 9:7-8 (NKJV) In Galatians Paul says that he was converted by direct revelation of Christ, that he did not go to Jerusalem at that time, but went instead to "Arabia." After that, he returned to Damascus. 1:16-17), whereas the book of Acts says that that was the first thing he did after leaving Damascus (Acts 9:26 . critical classification of the narratives of Paul's conversion/call. Acts 9, Shabir Ally argued, claimed that the companions of Saul of Tarsus did not hear the voice of the risen Christ, while Acts 22, Dr. deceived by others 4.) Skeptics have claimed that there is a contradiction in these two accounts regarding the witnesses of Saul's experience. It only says, "And when Saul had come to Jerusalem.". The transformation of persecuting Saul of Tarsus into the apostle Paul is a typical example of the work of grace in the heart. There are conflicting accounts of Paul's conversion. First, it marked his conversion to Christianity; second, it constituted his call to be a prophet; and third, it served as his commission to be an apostle. Ehrman writes, "These are just a few of the discrepancies that one can . In chapter 9, the witnesses, "heard the voice, but saw no one.". As early as 1932, Hans Windisch and others had noted the similarity in structure between Paul's conversion in Acts and the Heliodorus legend in 2 Maccabees 3 and other Hellenistic parallels.9 Recently Gerhard Lohfink has analyzed the Christophany in Acts 9:4-6, 22:7-10, (Paul Carlson: New Testament Contradictions) "Some translations of the Bible (the New International Version and the New . The first says that they didn't see anyone and the second says that they did see light. All conversions are in a high degree similar to this pattern conversion. He received his Bachelor of Science degree in Education from Ohio State University in 1968 and his Master of Education degree in Secondary School Administration in 1978 from Wright State University. At first reading the conversion accounts seem to present a contradiction. No two of these accounts are exactly the same. 2. 5. Ally claimed, affirmed that Paul's companions did har the voice of the Lord Jesus. . No, Paul did no go straight to Jerusalem after his conversion. Watch the video below to find out.
Acts 22:9 reads, "And they that were with me [Paul] saw indeed the light, and were afraid; but they heard not the voice of . He essentially wrote half of the New Testament as he carried the gospel far and wide. Paul's Conversion. Paul's conversion: Contradictory accounts? Paul considered himself to be charged directly by Jesus to preach the same message. A List of Contradictory and Incompatible Statements. This removes the idea of any contradiction. Luke and Paul probably discussed the conversion story in depth. As early as 1932, Hans Windisch and others had noted the similarity in structure between Paul's conversion in Acts and the Heliodorus legend in 2 Maccabees 3 and other Hellenistic parallels.9 Recently Gerhard Lohfink has analyzed the Christophany in Acts 9:4-6, 22:7-10, But supplementation is not the same as contradiction. Acts 9:7 states, "And the men which journeyed with him [Paul] stood speechless, hearing a voice, but seeing no man.". Paul's gospel is a grace gospel, not a kingdom gospel. Answer (1 of 22): Because Paul doesn't contradict Jesus's teachings. Listen to our Weekly Quick Challenge Question Podcast on iTunes, Google Play Music or Stitcher. There is no contradiction with Paul's encounter in Acts 9 or his testimony in Acts 22 or Acts 26 with this letter. This lack of harmony concerning Paul's conversion in Acts not only betrays a lack of personal knowledge of Paul, but that its author or authors were using more than one source to recount the tale of Paul's conversion. Paul's life is a reflection of Jesus life , it's the reason Paul seems exalted to Gentiles they hadn't known the scriptures but Paul was a Pharisee and knew them well he was able to take the message in the prophets and speak it to Gentiles intelligibly to explain the revelation of Christ they hold without the hearer having to know scripture. Messages: 9,638. The former indicates a hearing of the sound, the latter indicates the meaning or . After all, it was the "Apostle" Paul. The biggest contradiction is Pauline Christianity dealing with Paul's conversion. THE CONVERSION OF SAINT PAUL THE VALIDITY OF HIS TESTIMONY TO THE RESURRECTION OF JESUS CHRIST Rev. And Ananias even administers a baptismal rite aimed at washing away sins (Acts 22:16), just as John does (Luke 3:3). 4:14), Luke, describes Saul on a journey to Damascus. another new testament illustration of this literary phenomenon is the record of paul's conversion, as set forth three times in the book of acts (chapters 9, 22, and 26).this repetition has puzzled some sincere bible students.others, searching for flaws in the sacred scriptures, contend that the repetition is superfluous and contradictory, and Each version is different, and this fact has led some critics to say that the accounts are contradictory.
Please explain the apparent contradiction between Acts 9:7 and 22:9, concerning Paul's conversion. crazy 3.) The Contradictions of Paul - Part 1 For a number of years I've raised an occasional eyebrow to some of Paul's teachings; but I never took the time to dig very deep. St. Paul says that the powers that be are ordained of God, and that we must not resist them. In this episode of The Tent Making Christianity QCQ Podcast, the team discusses whether there is a contradiction in Paul's conversion story. The stories differ slightly. Please explain the apparent contradiction between Acts 9:7 and 22:9, concerning Paul's conversion. Thus, regardless of how one works through the accounts of Paul's conversion, an appeal to different cases probably ought not form any part of the solution [Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics, 133-134]. 01 - Paul's Conversion -The Itineraries Of Paul. There is no contradiction because one can easily see light without seeing a person. A fter Paul's long exhortation to live without sin in our lives as Christians Romans 7:14 completely . (As I think I've said, unlike some scholars I have no problem calling the earliest followers of Jesus who came to believe in his resurrection "Christian.") The best known and most important conversion was Paul. . Paul's conversion experience on the Damascus Road, which we'll explore in more depth tomorrow, is the source of his immense inner authority and most of his themes. June 16, 2016. Paul's gospel of salvation is Christ died for our sins and rose again (1 Corinthians 15.1-4). HUMANIST QUESTION: As a final example of a New Testament contradiction, the conflicting accounts of Paul's conversion can be cited.Acts 9:7 states that when Jesus called Paul to preach the gospel, the men who were with Paul heard a voice but saw no man. By Erik Manning. In his October 1, 2000 Angelus address in St. Peter's Square, Pope John Paul II said, "The document [Dominus Iesus] thus expresses once again the same ecumenical passion that is the basis of my encyclical Ut Unum Sint.I hope this declaration, which is close to my heart, can, after so many erroneous interpretations, finally fulfill its function both of clarification and openness" (Zenit . No Contradiction . Good question. Paul admits to stealing. As you continue to read in acts and his letters to the saints, you will see his faithfulness to Jesus, who he once persecuted. January 31, . The company's filing status is listed as Active and its File Number is 10284758-0151. To bring the Messiah and his message of redemption to the world. In Acts there are three testimonies of Paul's conversion on his way to Damascus.
As we will see over the next three weeks, all of Paul's major themes are contained in seed form in his conversion experience, of which there are three descriptions in Acts (chapters 9, 22, and 26). The criticism is that there are contradictions in them. We will have no other preface, but proceed at once to two or three considerations. I've copied a footnote from my lesson on the text in Galatians 1 which addresses your question: 35 Paul's account of his first visit to Jerusalem does not conflict with that of Luke in Acts 9:26-30. When was Paul's first visit to Jerusalem after his conversion? The conversion of Saul/Paul is so important to the author of the Book of Acts that he presents the story three times (Acts 9, 22, 26). The first is not difficult, for the two passages don't contain any apparent discrepancy. Jimmy was born in Texas, grew up nominally Protestant, but at age 20 experienced a profound conversion to Christ. As stated in part 1 of the Contradictions of Paul; in 2010 my eyes were opened regarding Paul, the supposed "apostle to the Gentiles." At that time, I began to see how Paul's words did not lineup with the teachings of Jesus Christ. According to both sources, . Book Of Mormon Contradiction: Alma 18:24-29 June 28, 2022; Today's Prayer (06/27/2022) June 27, 2022; Eph.4:28. Don't see your podcast listening platform? There is no contradiction because one can easily see light without seeing a person. Resolving the contradiction involves translating and in Acts 9:7 as "hear" and "sound" respectively, but translating the same words in Acts 22:9 as "understand" and "voice". All conversions are in a high degree similar to this pattern conversion. Apr 22, 2021. The story of Paul's conversion from a devout Jew, violently persecuting believers in Jesus, to a devout Christian, fearlessly spreading the Gospel against all opposition, is found three times in Acts. He was a devout Jew who believed strongly in his faith and consequently persecuted the early Christians, participating even in the stoning of Stephen (Acts 7:58 says that the men stoning Stephen laid their coats at his feet). In Acts 9 it seems that the bystanders also heard the voice that was speaking to Paul, but in Acts 22 it seems that they didn't hear that voice. Luke tells us that Paul fled to Jerusalem from Damascus, attempted to associate with the "disciples" there (Acts 9:26), and was shunned until Barnabas took him to the . I won't go through every one point by point, but just for example: #2: Paul said "For I did not receive it [his doctrines] from man, now wa. The I tackle and refute all 51 supposed Bible "contradictions" suggested by anti-theist atheist Paul Carlson in his pathetic hit-piece, "New Testament Contradictions" (The Secular Web, 1995). . The following statements from Paul's letters are symptomatic of deep differences between the doctrines of Paul and Jesus -- much as a fever is symptomatic of an infection in the body. Paul's conversion experience is discussed in both the Pauline epistles and in the Acts of the Apostles. Joseph L. Lilly, C.M., S.T.D., S.S.L. The first account, in Acts 9, narrated Paul's conversion when it actually happened. The man quoted more often than Jesus, from the gospel accounts. Paul's conversion experience on the Damascus Road, which we'll explore in more depth tomorrow, is the source of his immense inner authority and most of his themes. The Historicity of Paul the Apostle. First there was the brief historical sketch by Luke in Acts 9. . 3. The man noted for writing the lion's share of the New Testament. Interestingly, in each case we have three accounts of their conversions: Paul's conversion is reported in Acts 9, 22, and 26. The intensity of St. Paul's feelings, smarting . Each version is different, and this fact has led some critics to say that the accounts are contradictory. Armed with pontifical letters of authorization to the synagogues His name is George Lyttleton.